Many African leaders have used the term ‘We Africans’ in their speeches and statements. Subsequently, many researches and works based on findings in one African society have been deemed to be relevant elsewhere in Africa. For example there are books on African organizations, on the African management style, on African values…Those pieces of work are never based on empirical studies covering the entire continent.
For many years, I relied on the opinions and statements of prominent experts and leaders about Africa culture. Only by living and working in different African countries, did I learn to understand the empirical evidence of the numerous cultural differences between Africans. Even when Africans share some common values, they can express those values differently. Therefore, what may be right and respectable in one culture becomes improper and disrespectful in another place. Even common values may have different ranks in a particular culture’s hierarchy of values.
But could so many distinguished experts and leaders be wrong?
It took me
several years to solve this riddle. The mystery began to unravel when I attended a performance given by two groups of artists, an Ethiopian dance group and a Japanese group of drum players. In
spite of the totally different performances offered, the officials of both countries went on stage and commented on how much they share in common. They could not be more wrong!
I was attempting resolve their incongruous emphasis on commonality and trying to figure out why they had not emphasized the beauty of their cultural differences, when I remembered a major difference between individualistic societies and group-based or collectivist ones.
In individualistic societies, differences are beautiful. They are studied and the subject of much interest and many comparisons. In group-oriented societies, commonalities rather than differences are preferred as they ensure the harmony between the members of the groups.
The discovery of the explanation of African leaders and experts’ focus on their commonalities makes it clear that their true message had not been properly understood. They just had no interest in looking at their differences as that the expression of difference threatens the groups’ harmony.
Subsequently many foreigners but also many Africans have been misled. This situation yields many adverse outcomes:
Intra African cultural differences related to working with Africans have been widely overlooked in most literatures. That was maybe not too problematic when Africans were isolated but today Africans are engaged in an increasing number of international collaborations with fellows from other African societies. Their lack of awareness of the cultural differences inside Africa does not help them in bringing effectiveness to their collaborations.
On the other side, the liberalization of African economies means that today stakeholders who had no colonial past in Africa operate on the continent without a any cultural sensitivity or awareness.
The paucity of cross-cultural literature on Africa (especially the Anglophone literature) creates a situation where the possible resources deliver country-specific training on the basis of assumed commonalities between their country they know and other African ones.
It is therefore urgent to devote time and energy in exploring the intra-African cultural differences and in equipping all stakeholders with the cross-cultural competences that would enhance the effectiveness of international collaborations.
Write a comment
Joe Kearns (Wednesday, 02 December 2020 11:42)
Great piece Pascale. Some really interesting and thought provoking comments that merit further conversation.
Jose Vargas (Tuesday, 08 December 2020 21:39)
Great article Pascale, I agree ! I spend also a good traveling in Africa about 23 different countries from the nice South Africa to the deep Congo and spend 2 years in the Franco Phone Countries , from the finance point of view they need to stand as owner of the mines and resources politicians are the ones that don provide standing for their own people, Africa is the RESERVE of this every planet in several industries, the big Corporations ,Africa have every thing to an active Continent , the finance and many projects still waiting, Africa deserve to be better!!
"Those pieces of work are never based on empirical studies covering the entire continent." absolutely truth!!
I think to talk about this nice Continent and great people, you need to life there, like you Pascale, also I spend about seven years, and people in UN they love to talk Africa but only a few have been there.
To talk about Africa is something special, great Job Pascale.
Sibylle Ganz-Koechlin (Monday, 14 December 2020 10:24)
Well said, Pascale!